FAQs

Cupcake bakeries are everywhere these days! What makes Silver Lining different?

Silver Lining is locally-owned and independent. Each and every cupcake you buy from us is made from scratch in our bakery each morning using ingredients you can recognize and pronounce!  We bake with the same stuff our mothers and grandmothers did–flour, sugar, butter, and eggs. Absolutely nothing is outsourced in our bakery, and you’ll never find us using pre-mixed batters or frostings. We put true time and effort into creating a quality homemade product, and we believe you’ll taste the difference in every bite.

I want cupcakes! Should I pre-order or visit the store?

Pre-ordering is best if you know exactly what which flavors you’d like and you want to grab your cupcakes and go! If you pre-order, you may select up to two different flavors for each dozen you order. If you prefer to choose a wider variety of cupcake flavors, you’re always welcome to drop in and make your selection. We have a rotating selection of cupcake flavors in our store daily.

How much are cupcakes?

Cupcakes are $2.50 each, $14.00 for a half-dozen, and $25.00 for a full dozen.

Where is Silver Lining Cupcake Co. located?

We are on Baxter Street, in the Baxter Street Lofts Building, right next to the Mirko Pasta.

What is the best way to keep my cupcakes fresh?

Cupcakes are at their most delicious when consumed the day of your purchase; however, if you’ll be keeping them overnight, it’s best to refrigerate them and then set them out at least 30 minutes before enjoying so that the buttercream or cream cheese frosting can come up to room temperature. If you keep your cupcakes longer than a few days, you may want to microwave them for 10 seconds to soften them up a bit before consumption.

Do you make gluten-free/sugar-free/vegan cupcakes?

Most of our cupcakes can be made gluten-free upon special order using gluten-free flour. Gluten-free cupcakes are $30.00 per dozen. We are currently experimenting with sugar-free and vegan recipes and will let you know as soon as we have yummy sugar-free and vegan options.

I want to order cupcakes, but my favorite cupcake flavor isn’t listed on your menu…

Give us a call! Because we are local and independent, we have the freedom to get creative! If you have a favorite you don’t see on our menu, let us know and we can do a little research and then give you our take on it. Who knows, it may even be added to our regular rotation!

We are also constantly expanding our menu. The best way to stay updated on our latest creations is to follow us on Facebook and/or Twitter, where we post our flavor selections each morning.

Do you have your entire menu selection in-store each day?

No. We have a selection of 7-10 different menu flavors to choose from each day; however, our four most popular flavors–The Scarlett, Nutty Chocolate, Birthday Cake, and Vanilla Twilight–are part of the selection every day.

Can you do cupcakes for my wedding/shower/special event?

Absolutely! Cupcake pricing for special events is the same as our regular cupcake pricing. For weddings, we can also create custom mini cakes to top your cupcake tier. We are always happy to work with you to create a custom look for your special day. Please contact us for more details.

Do you deliver?

We do deliver within a five mile radius for a $10 fee. The delivery fee includes a ribbon and a personalized note, if desired.

@ Click here to Make an Order Online

Our news